My Car Starts Sometimes And Sometimes It Doesn’t: Means

My Car Starts Sometimes And Sometimes It Doesn't

Few things are more frustrating than a car that starts intermittently. One day, it’s running fine; the next, it stubbornly refuses to start. Intermittent starting issues can leave you stuck, late, and unsure whether it’s safe to trust your car. 

Unlike more straightforward problems, this kind of issue can stem from various causes, some of which are easy to fix, while others might require professional diagnosis. In this guide, we’ll cover the most common reasons why a car might start inconsistently. 

We’ll explore electrical and mechanical components, explain how to diagnose the issue, and provide practical solutions to restore your car’s reliability. By the end of this guide, you’ll have a thorough understanding of what might be causing the problem, so you can take the right steps to fix it.

Common Causes

Understanding the factors that could be behind your car’s inconsistent starting is essential to finding the right solution. Here are some of the most common causes:

A. Battery-Related Issues

A failing or weak battery is often the first suspect when a car has trouble starting. Although the battery may have enough charge to start your car sometimes, it may struggle to provide adequate power consistently.

  • Battery Terminals and Cables: Loose or corroded battery terminals can hinder power flow. Even a minor disconnection can prevent the battery from delivering the necessary voltage, leading to intermittent starts.
  • Battery Health: Over time, batteries lose their ability to hold a charge, particularly in extreme temperatures. If the battery is old, it might be near the end of its lifespan.

Solution: Clean the battery terminals to remove any corrosion, ensure the cables are tight, and test the battery’s voltage with a multimeter. If the battery is weak or old, replacing it may resolve the problem.

B. Faulty Starter Motor

The starter motor is responsible for initiating the engine’s cranking motion. If it’s worn or damaged, it can struggle to start the car consistently.

  • Worn Brushes or Solenoid: The starter motor consists of brushes and a solenoid that can wear out over time, resulting in inconsistent starting performance.
  • Loose Connections: Loose connections to the starter can also prevent it from working reliably.

Solution: A mechanic can test the starter motor to determine if it’s functioning correctly. If worn out, it may require rebuilding or replacing.

C. Ignition Switch Problems

An ignition switch is what controls the power to most of the car’s electronic systems and the starter. Faulty ignition switches can intermittently fail to engage these systems.

  • Loose Internal Contacts: Over time, the internal contacts in the ignition switch can wear or become loose, leading to sporadic power loss.
  • Worn Key Cylinder: The key cylinder itself may also wear out, especially if you use heavy keychains, which can strain the ignition switch.

Solution: Replacing a faulty ignition switch is often necessary if the internal contacts are worn.

D. Issues with Fuel Delivery

For an engine to start, it needs a precise mixture of fuel and air. If the fuel system isn’t delivering fuel reliably, the car may struggle to start.

  • Fuel Pump Problems: The fuel pump sends gasoline from the tank to the engine. If it’s failing, you may hear it working intermittently or not at all, causing inconsistent starts.
  • Clogged Fuel Filter: A blocked fuel filter can restrict fuel flow, making it difficult for the engine to start, especially after the car has been sitting idle.

Solution: Listen for the fuel pump’s sound when turning the key to the “on” position. If it sounds weak or is silent, it may need replacement. Changing a clogged fuel filter may also help.

E. Faulty Crankshaft Position Sensor

The crankshaft position sensor informs the car’s computer of the crankshaft’s position, allowing the engine to fire correctly. A faulty sensor can send incorrect signals, preventing the car from starting.

  • Temperature Sensitivity: Some crankshaft position sensors fail when the engine is warm but work when it’s cold, causing erratic starting behavior.

Solution: A mechanic can test the crankshaft position sensor to confirm if it’s working. If it’s faulty, replacing it should solve the issue.

Diagnosing an Intermittent Starting Problem

Properly diagnosing why your car starts inconsistently can save you time and money. Here’s how to diagnose the problem:

A. Start with the Battery

Begin by inspecting the battery, as it’s the most common cause. Ensure that the terminals are clean and firmly attached. Use a multimeter to check if the battery voltage is around 12.6 volts when the car is off. If it’s below this, the battery may be weak.

B. Test the Starter Motor

If the battery is working well, turn your attention to the starter motor. You can check this by having someone turn the ignition while you listen for clicking sounds near the starter. If there’s a clicking noise but no engine turnover, the starter motor may need attention.

C. Check the Ignition Switch

If the starter and battery seem fine, examine the ignition switch. Try wiggling the key while attempting to start the car. If the car starts when you do this, the ignition switch may be the culprit.

D. Inspect Fuel Delivery

To check if the fuel system is to blame, turn the key to the “on” position without starting the car. You should hear a faint whirring sound from the fuel pump. If you don’t hear it or it sounds weak, the fuel pump might need replacing.

E. Scan for Error Codes

If you have an OBD-II scanner, use it to check for error codes. Intermittent starting issues can sometimes trigger codes related to sensors, such as the crankshaft position sensor, helping you identify the problem.

Potential Solutions for Intermittent Starting Issues

Once you’ve diagnosed the issue, here are the solutions for each common problem:

A. Battery Maintenance and Replacement

If a weak or faulty battery is the problem, it’s usually best to replace it, especially if it’s older than three years. Regularly clean the terminals and ensure they’re tightly connected.

B. Starter Motor Repair

Replacing the starter motor can resolve intermittent starting issues related to worn brushes or a faulty solenoid. Rebuild kits are available for some starter motors if replacement is costly.

C. Ignition Switch Replacement

If the ignition switch is found to be faulty, replacing it will typically resolve the issue. In many cases, this will involve a mechanic if you’re unfamiliar with electrical components.

D. Fuel System Repairs

Replacing a failing fuel pump or clogged fuel filter can improve fuel flow, making starts more reliable. Ensure the fuel system is regularly maintained for optimal performance.

E. Sensor Replacement

If diagnostics indicate a faulty crankshaft position sensor, replacing it is necessary to restore reliable starting performance.

Tips for Buying Intermittent Starting Issue Parts

When purchasing replacement parts for an intermittent starting issue, keep these factors in mind:

A. Battery Selection

  • Cold Cranking Amps (CCA): Higher CCA ratings indicate better performance in cold weather, which is useful if your region experiences harsh winters.
  • Warranty: Choose a battery with a good warranty for added peace of mind.

B. Quality of Starter Motors

  • Rebuilt vs. New: New starter motors are typically more reliable, but rebuilt options can be a cost-effective choice.
  • Compatibility: Ensure the starter motor matches your vehicle model for proper fit and performance.

C. Fuel Pump Choices

  • Brand Reputation: Some aftermarket brands may not last as long as OEM parts, so consider the reputation of the brand when selecting a fuel pump.
  • Noise Level: Some pumps are noisier than others. Look for user reviews on noise levels if it’s a concern.

D. Sensor Accuracy

  • OEM Sensors: OEM sensors typically provide better compatibility and reliability, particularly for sensors critical to engine performance.
  • Warranty: Opt for sensors with a warranty to cover potential defects.

E. Ignition Components

  • OEM vs. Aftermarket: OEM ignition switches are generally more reliable, but quality aftermarket options are available at a lower cost.
  • Durability: Look for ignition switches made with durable materials, as they’re less likely to wear out quickly.

Tips for Maintaining Starting Reliability

Here are a few extra tips to keep your car starting consistently in the future:

  • Regularly Inspect Battery Terminals: Corrosion can accumulate over time, causing issues.
  • Drive Regularly: If your car sits idle for long periods, the battery may drain, leading to intermittent starts.
  • Stay on Top of Fuel Filter Changes: A clean fuel filter helps ensure a smooth fuel flow to the engine.
  • Avoid Excessive Use of Accessories When the Engine Is Off: Running accessories like the radio or AC when the engine is off can drain the battery faster.
  • Listen to the Car’s Starting Sounds: Unusual sounds can often indicate potential issues with the starter or battery, allowing for early intervention.

Conclusion

A car that starts inconsistently can be a hassle, but with the right approach to diagnosing and fixing the problem, you can return to reliable, worry-free driving. By understanding the common causes—whether it’s the battery, starter, fuel system, or ignition—you’ll have a clearer path to resolving these intermittent issues. 

Addressing the problem proactively and performing regular maintenance will not only save you from frustration but also help prolong the life of your vehicle. With the information in this guide, you’re better equipped to identify, diagnose, and solve any starting problems you may encounter, ensuring your car is always ready when you are.

Stephen Madison
Follow me
Share This Post

Leave a Reply